Home / Blog / Sponsored Reviews / Review of AdminPraise2 Template 
Alledia.com Blog
Apr
08
2009
Review of AdminPraise2 Template
Sponsored Reviews
Written by Steve Burge   
Avatar

This is a review of the AdminPraise2 template from JoomlaPraise. In fact I should clarify that description: AdminPraise2 is only a template in the way that some of the largest and most ambitious frontend templates are ... closer to an serious of extensions than a simple template. AdminPraise2 changes the look and feel of Joomla's administrator area but also adds an enormous amount of functionality.

Logging In

Lets start at the beginning. Immediately upon logging in, you see a couple of nice new touches, including links for administrators to recover their details.

AdminPraise2 Login

Main Admin Screen

AdminPraise2 Main Layout

When you login to the main admin area, you immediately notice that almost everything is different:

  • There are now two layers of menus across the top.
  • Lots more of the navigation is persistent, including the boxes on the right-hand side of the screen and the logged-in users list at the bottom.
  • The links in the top-right are much more useful than normal, including the ability to switch WYSIWYG editors, change the admin template or go full-screen.
  • There's a Mac-style toolbar menu across the bottom:
AdminPraise2 Toolbar

Other Interesting Features

There are a lot of graphically interesting features including some large, graphical menus for components and module:

AdminPraise2 Components Menu

There's also a customizeable, retractable right-hand column into which you can insert modules of your choice:

AdminPraise2 Modules

There's also a recent activity section so you can see who's been doing what:

AdminPraise2 Recent Activity

So Far So Good, But What About the Real Power of AdminPraise2?

I'm glad you asked. The real power lies not in the new default settings but in the abilty AdminPraise2 gives you to choose your own layout.

Click on "Admin Modules" and you'll find that almost everything is customizeable and not just on a hide/show level, but on a Manager/Administrator/SuperAdministrator level. Most of the admin customization I've seen has been limited to people replacing Joomla's branding with their own or a single link on the control panel to a favorite component.

AP allows you to prepare a completely customized backend for clients. If they run a directory, place all the important add / edit / delete listing links in plain view. If they run a photo site, place the upload / manage / media links where they're easy to find. You can also do some ACL-style changes and remove everything you choose from out of the view of Managers and Administrators.

This is the real power of AdminPraise2 ... you have the ability to design a backend to your clients needs rather than needing to teach them how to navigate the unneeded links in Khepri2.

Things To Work On

  • More tooltips would be helpful for some of the backend links, particularly where they differ from Khepri.
  • Some links such as "Legacy On / Off" could be replaced by more common ones such as "New User" or "New Category"
  • Not all of the links are clear, for example the template and WYSIWYG changes in the top-right corner.
  • Some of the links are perhaps repetitive ... I saw 5 ways to get into the Section Manager, for example.
  • Quite a few links under "Installer" are really for uninstalling.
  • Joomla extension developers haven't caught up to the idea of custom templates yet, witness the lack of backend images for components and modules.

Conclusion

I'm not sure you need AdminPraise2 if you're an experienced Joomla developer, but I'm certain you could build a better site for your clients with it. With a little practice you could customize the backend as carefully as you do the frontend.

I also really appreciate the imagination of Kyle and his team. No-one else is building administrator templates but even without any rivals it seems as if they're pushing the envelope, opening a lot of interesting new doors for Joomla.

 

Comments  

 
#1 Kyle Ledbetter 2009-04-08 16:57
Great review, many thanks Steve :-)

I just wanted to respond to a couple points:

Quote:
Some links such as "Legacy On / Off" could be replaced by more common ones such as "New User" or "New Category"

All the links everywhere are configurable and can easily be swapped out in the AP Icons module, which is used everywhere.

Quote:
Not all of the links are clear, for example the template and WYSIWYG
We just crunched that space down w/this release for smaller monitors, maybe icons are in order?

Quote:
Some of the links are perhaps repetitive ... I saw 5 ways to get into the Section Manager, for example.
Agreed, we intend for every user to pick which one they like and hide the rest.

Quote:
Quite a few links under "Installer" are really for uninstalling
I love having these shortcuts for uninstalling, but I totally agree. I think they're calling this "Extensions Manager" in 1.6, so we can change "Installer" to "Extensions"

Quote:
not sure you need AdminPraise2 if you're an experienced Joomla developer
I'd challenge any Joomla vet to use it for a week and try to stop :-)

Lastly, I wanted to mention a couple of hidden features that I love:
- History Crumbs: I couldn't live w/o my history crumbs!
- Last visited page: if you're logged out and log back in you go right back to the same page
- Set Start: click this to set ANY admin page as your 1st page on login
- NinjaXplorer: the editor window is MUCH bigger in AP2
Quote
 
 
#2 Brian Teeman 2009-04-08 17:37
I had the suprise of using this template the other day on a client site.

I can see where it is coming from and it is a welcome effort to improve the UI and UX of the joomla admin.

But the big problem I found was that if you are running on a small screen (I use 1024*600 on an asus eee) it was pretty unusable. On a large screen I can see that all the extras would add to things but on the small screen they really got in the way.

I'm all for user choice so concepts like this and will surely lead others to consider the UI and UX of the admin side of joomla which has been pretty neglected by everyone.

One thing I did find confusing was that are many places where functions are repeated.
Quote
 
 
#3 Ken 2009-04-08 18:33
I love AP2!. I have been a JoomlaPraise customer for about 6 months. The support is great, and the add-ons are useful and stable.

Brian, I find the repeated functions handy, because if I am thinking, and sometimes I am, it seems that the function I need is right next to my mouse cursor position.
Quote
 
 
#4 Sam 2009-04-08 21:33
AP2 Rocks! Takes Joomla to the next level. Anyone serous about deploying sites for non-geeks needs this. Screen can be eaten up by the doc menu at the bottom. Looks cool, but our users get tired of accidentally triggering it when they scroll down the a bit. If it was half the size it would be better IMO. We turned it off. I was sorry to see the doc menu go...because it was so cool.
Quote
 
 
#5 Ken 2009-04-08 21:46
Have to agree...halve the docmenu.
Quote
 
 
#6 Winston 2009-04-09 08:31
I'm using it too, and I love it so far.

I agree with the dock sentiments. The template works great when I'm working on a larger screen, but on 1024x768, things get a little cramped.

My one complaint is that I have a lot of muscle memory that keeps taking me up to the logout button when editing things (intending to close, but I keep logging out.)
Quote
 
 
#7 Kyle Ledbetter 2009-04-09 08:48
Quote:
muscle memory that keeps taking me up to the logout button when editing things

That would tick me off too :D

The logout is in the same position. Maybe it's the scale of the icon and that the icons are floated right in Khepri... If this is a real problem for folks I'll have it changed to a different icon.
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh