Home / Product Reviews / Review of WordPress for Joomla by corePHP.com 
Product Reviews
Nov
19
2009
Review of WordPress for Joomla by corePHP.com
Written by Steve Burge   
Avatar

Wordpress for JoomlaWe've always used Joomla as our blog platform of choice here at Alledia. People are  always surprised by that, which is pleasing ... it took a lot of work. We needed a whole variety of different extensions to create the normal features of a blog.

Because it requires quite a bit of effort, Joomla developers have long looked enviously at Wordpress and the default blogging features it has. Several have tried to bridge Wordpress into Joomla including MojoBlog. The latest and perhaps the most comprehensive is WordPress for Joomla by corePHP.com.

Installation

This was surprisingly easy. Wordpress has been turned into com_wordpress and it installs directly from Joomla's installer. Its a large file but installation simply consists of uploading the component - no extra plugins or uploads needed.

Comparing the Original Wordpress to Wordpress for Joomla

I haven't done a full review of all the features of Wordpress for Joomla - that really would be reinventing the wheel.

What I have done is carefully compare the original Wordpress to the Joomla version. Essentially the differences are few:

  • Wordpress plugins and themes: they need modifications - often substantial - to work with WforJ..
  • Widgets: All the default widgets are available. They're placed into special "Sidebar modules" for Joomla. Sidebar1 is one module, Sidebar2 is another, Sidebar 3 is a fourth and so on. That means you can use all of Wordpress' normal widgets.
Those were the only two meaningful changes I found. Otherwise, Wordpress have been moved into Joomla untouched - there's been no Joomla-fication of the system. Here's a comparison of the admin options in the two versions:
Original
W. for JoomlaOriginal
W. for Joomla
Review of WordPress for Joomla by corePHP.comReview of WordPress for Joomla by corePHP.comReview of WordPress for Joomla by corePHP.comReview of WordPress for Joomla by corePHP.com

Is it Worth Putting Wordpress into Joomla?

This is a question that has been asked and you may be wondering about. My answer is ... it depends.

  • Cons - Plenty of Joomla template clubs make matching Wordpress and Joomla so its easy to get a integrated design without this product.
  • Pros - By integrating Wordpress into Joomla people only need a single login to comment on posts.
  • Cons - As with any bridge, you are essentially relying not only the developers of the two original products, but also the developer of the bridge.
  • Pros - corePHP have done a great job with regular updates so far and the code is unecrypted should that change.
  • Cons - The Wordpress categories, tags, comments and RSS don't integrate with Joomla so if you're already tagging articles or allowing comments, this won't work with your existing set-up.
  • Pros - I've no real answer to that one. Just know in advance that you're getting Wordpress inside Joomla, not Wordpress integrated into Joomla. However, content plugins can be enabled inside the blog.

A Better Blog Than Joomla Itself or a Native Extension?

We use default Joomla for this blog. How does Wordpress for Joomla compare?

  • Better: We've had to cobble our blog together using a variety of extensions. Wordpress for Joomla ships with tags, multiple-categories, comments, RSS feeds, blog calendars ... you name it, its an all-in-one package.
  • Worse: Its simply more to learn. If you're using this for a client, you need to teach them Joomla and then Wordpress as well.

How about MyBlog from Azrul.com, which is a popular Joomla blogging extension?

  • Better: As above, its just a more complete solution. It has multiple-categories, comments, blog calendars ... you name it, its an all-in-one package.
  • Worse: I definitely prefer the multi-user blogging capabilities of MyBlog as it visually much more closely integrated into Joomla and so easier for non-technical people. Each person can also have their own blog page. Finally there's also more support for social networking extensions such as Community Builder and JomSocial (from the same developer).

Would I use Wordpress for Joomla? Yes, absolutely. It has more features and options than any other blogging option for Joomla. I'd mainly use it on sites where:

    1. The blogger(s) don't mind learning, or already know, both Joomla and Wordpress.
    2. A single login is important.
    3. You'd like a lot more features than are available with default Joomla or other blog extensions.

      This was a sponsored review. The developers were not paying for an opinion, only for our time to give the product a thorough testing. For more information about sponsored reviews, please click here.

       

      Comments  

       
      #1 Richard Pearce 2009-11-22 13:44
      I've not quite understood the point of this either but I'm curious to give it a go now. Nice review.
      Quote
       
       
      #2 Steve Burge 2009-11-22 17:08
      Hi Richard - I didn't either for quite a while.

      Its certainly overkill for certain sites, but if you need WP-power and a single login, its a good option.
      Quote
       
       
      #3 IT Support London 2009-11-22 20:05
      You can take a look at how the wordpress blog looks on a real webpage by visiting IT Support London (www.sysfix.co.uk). We've been using it for a while and it's doing the job nicely.

      Menu item to blog on green bar for demo.
      Quote
       
       
      #4 Colin Welch 2009-11-23 09:11
      Hi Steve - this is a useful summary, and your comments about the simplicity of Wordpress vs. Joomla are also interesting. The consensus among our clients is generally that Joomla is worth the extra effort for the improved functionality it gives, especially for businesses.

      We've written our own short piece at www.siliconbeachtraining.co.uk/blog/joomla-vs-wordpress-comparison/
      Quote
       
       
      #5 sungoddess 2009-11-23 17:42
      I've been running it for about a year, and it's great... plenty of quirks for sure, but it's opened a whole new world for me, and gave my aged blog new life.

      It's also a very nerdy exercise for me in hacking and such to get it to do everything I want, but I totally agree about it not being ideal for noobs unless you give it to them via a desktop client... yet, I really do like the hybrid. Can't help myself... it's the best of both worlds for me regarding my blog.

      I've considered switching to WP fully, but the power of Joomla extensions makes me stop everytime... as much as I love WP as a standalone, I get a little frustrated with the way it handles content occasionally, and the way you can layer a Joomla site is it's main attraction for me as a builder/developer.

      So I dunno... I see all your points and agree, but I am converted regarding my own blog, quirks and all.
      Quote
       
       
      #6 Sean Cook 2009-12-11 02:23
      Thanks Steve.

      Would this be better for SEO than MyBlog, or are they about the same?
      Quote
       
       
      #7 Steve Burge 2009-12-11 07:18
      Probably yes - MyBlog's URL structure is very messy. It can cause a lot of duplicate content.
      Quote
       
       
      #8 John Langlois 2010-01-31 11:41
      Do you know whether the "Thesis" theme for wordpress will work in this context?
      Quote
       
       
      #9 amanda 2010-02-10 22:05
      I'm also wondering if thesis will work! Please? :-)
      Quote
       
       
      #10 Steve Burge 2010-02-11 07:12
      Hi John and Amanda - I don't want to speak for CorePHP but I suspect it's highly unlikely. It would need a LOT of modification to work inside Joomla.
      Quote
       

      Add comment


      Security code
      Refresh