Feb 13 2008
Review of SmartSEF Print
Wednesday, 13 February 2008

Richard and his team from Joomlatwork have been busy. Just a couple of weeks after releasing the SEF Patch, which greatly improves Joomla 1.5 metadata, they've launched SmartSEF, which greatly improves Joomla 1.5 URLs.


Here's our review of the beta version:

Why Do You Need Friendly URLs in Joomla 1.5?

To begin with, lets take a look at Joomla 1.5 default URLs:


  • Default URLs: index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=25&Itemid=28


These really have changed little since we cataloged the problems with these URLs in 1.0. So if those are no good, how about the default SEF URLs in 1.5:


  • Default SEF: component/content/article/3-newsflash/42-newsflash-4.html


I'm sure you'll agree that these are a huge advance over the SEF URLs in the core of 1.0. However, they still have some limitations:


  • numbers in the URLs
  • no choice over the URL suffix (.html, .php, .asp etc.)
  • lack of the advanced options we're used in component such as sh404SEF


If you're still not convinced, try "In Defence of Search Engine Friendly URLs".

My Impressions

  • Easy to Use. Installation is easy and an .htaccess file is provided. In its clean layouts and few, but important options, it reminds me of SEF Advanced. Almost all the configuration options are on a single tabless page.
  • Feature-Rich. it takes the most important options and ideas from sh404SEF. You can remove sections and categories, check for duplicate URLs, log 404 errors and cleanly strip awkward characters from the URLs.
  • Stable. I've not had the chance to use it on a live site yet, but during an intensive testing session we built up a database of 5000 URLs and the site did not slow or show any noticeable bugs.

Potential Weaknesses

  • Its Just Launched. Currently there aren't any plugins available for other components.
  • Uncertain Future. This is also an inevitable problem with a new component. Will it become the default solution for Joomla 1.5 URLs? Both Artio and SEF Advance may rival it soon.

Conclusion

I was very impressed with Smart SEF. Its clear when you first install that this is the work of an experience and talanted development team. For beta software that has had to track a moving target in Joomla 1.5, its hard to imagine in being much better.


Is it ready for live sites? Yes, although mainly for sites that do not use many components. If you want SEF URLs throughout your site, you'll need to wait for plugins.

Smart SEF Links

Read More

Image Gallery

Click image to open!

Comments (4)Add Comment
SEF Advance for Joomla 1.5
written by Yannick Gaultier, February 15, 2008
Looks like Emir has already released its own version : http://www.sakic.net/news/sef_...omla!_1.5/!

Regards
...
written by Steve Burge, February 15, 2008
Hi Yannick

In contrast to our stellar review of Smart SEF, we've tested SEF Advanced for 1.5 and weren't impressed. Reasons why:

1) Substantially fewer features and no features that SmartSEF doesn't possess
2) 100% encoded. I mean every single last file
3) $60 per site, compared to $0 for SmartSEF
...
written by Yannick Gaultier, February 16, 2008
Looks like I released my own version ! : http://extensions.siliana.net/...-beta.html

Regards
...
written by Zorro, February 17, 2008
Hi Yannick,

that's great news! For those running vital 3rd party components, it will be a lot easier to make the move to 1.5 in legacy mode.

The big question of course is, will you develop sh404SEF further to run as a native 1.5 component? smilies/smiley.gif

Keep up the good work and kind regards,
Zorro

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smile
wink
laugh
grin
angry
sad
shocked
cool
tongue
kiss
cry
smaller | bigger

busy
 
Joomla SEO Club and Book Logo
Search
Login
Blog Details

Subscribe by RSS

Creative Commons License All blog articles are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.
Top Comment Posters
Good Web Practices
(114 comments)
Klaus Nitsche
(78 comments)
Brian Teeman
(67 comments)
Hummerbie
(35 comments)
guido
(34 comments)
Ansiklopedi
(30 comments)
Amy Stephen
(29 comments)
Yannick Gaultier
(28 comments)
Cory
(27 comments)
Anthony Olsen
(18 comments)
Blog Categories
Accessibility
Affiliates
Alledia News
Analytics
Book Reviews
Business
Design
Domain Names
Domain Tips & Tricks
Drupal
E-Commerce
Extensions of the Month
General CMS Issues
Interviews
Joomla Affiliates
Joomla 1.5
Joomla Blogs
Joomla Hacks
Joomla Hosting
Joomla News
Joomla People
Joomla SEO eBook
Joomla SEO Rankings
Joomla Sites
Joomla South East
Joomla Templates
Joomla Tips & Tricks
Joomla URLs
Open Questions
PHP
Pay Per Click
Product Reviews
Rants
Scams
Recommended Sites
Search Engine Optimization
Security
SEO
SEO Club
SEO Competition
Site Reviews
Template Clubs
Yellow Pages
Virtuemart
Vlogs
Wordpress
Translate
right