Home / General CMS Issues / Joomla is a Hotbed of Innovation. Be Proud. 
General CMS Issues
Feb
05
2010
Joomla is a Hotbed of Innovation. Be Proud.
Written by Steve Burge   
Avatar

Since we expanded into Drupal and Wordpress training quite a few people have asked variations on these questions:

  • "Are you abandoning Joomla?"
  • "Do you think Drupal and Wordpress are now better than Joomla?"

The simple answers are no and no. Last summer we discussed how smart companies were now supporting several CMS platforms and gave some reasons why. I like to think we're just following our own advice.

I've another reason to add ... Joomla companies are remarkably dynamic and entrepreneurial. Looking back over the last few years, Joomla has been a remarkable hotbed of innovation, particularly when it comes two areas, business models and design:

Template Clubs

One of the WooThemes developers, the biggest themes site in Wordpress admitted that took the subscription model from the innovations of Joomla developers:

"We replicated the business model used by both RocketTheme.com & Yootheme.com, as they’d been very successful in the Joomla community and we wanted to bring that to the WordPress community." Link

If my memory serves me right, MamboSolutions were the first template club and Andy Miller followed with Mambodev (what would later become Rockettheme). Since then 100s of template clubs have sprung up all involved in a monthly arms race that helps them develop new ideas in:

LiteJazzRegionsTemplate Design

If you look at many Drupal and Wordpress templates, they clearly take lessons and ideas from Joomla designs techniques.

Take a look at LiteJazz from Roopletheme and you'll see not just design ideas from Joomla but even region positions ... User1, User2, User3 etc is an odd naming convention and taken directly from Joomla.

Commercial GPL Extensions

Selling extensions under the Commercial GPL and getting customers to pay for support and documentation? A lot of Joomla companies bravely pushed into that area. We interviewed the only 5 commercial GPL developers we could find back in mid-2007. Even several of those 5 were unsure and hesitant about the new model. That same month Daniel from Ninjaforge.com and Vic from Anything-Digital succesfully released their products under the GPL license, paving the way for many more to follow.

That Innovation is Still Continuing

So far we haven't seen many (any?) companies from other platforms try to release for Joomla. Woothemes may be the first this year many Joomla companies are continuing their innovation and stretching their wings.

Drupal is innovating in it's own way, expanding into the corporate and government sectors, and Wordpress is doing a great job of gaining marketshare for Open Source in many industries.

However, be proud of what Joomla and the people involved with it have achieved. The number of Joomla firms expanding to Drupal, Wordpress, Magento, and phpBB3 speaks of Joomla's strength not its weakness. This is another first from hardworking and entrepreneurial developers who continue to build an industry full of innovation.

 

Comments  

 
#1 Phil de Gruchy 2010-02-05 09:38
Too true Steve. As the use of CMS continues to increase the different products will start to concentrate on different sectors of the market.

Joomla in my opinion is a great all rounder, but some projects are much better suited to say WordPress.

The Joomla team are doing a great job and I'm hoping v1.6 delivers once again.
Quote
 
 
#2 tfernandez 2010-02-05 18:29
I've recently forced myself to finally make the wordpress leap (having cut my teeth with Joomla 1.5) primarily due to a new [url:error] for the real estate industry.

Initially, WP felt really limiting and a bit stale in terms of theme designs and options, but after reviewing many premium WP themes (via themeforest.com) and WP theme frameworks like Thesis and Headway I feel differently. Id even say that on the framework side, Thesis and Headway seem superior to Joomla's equivalents Morph and Gantry, though I haven't personally used Gantry.

I hope to see continued Joomla innovation but with the delays of 1.6 and the relative staleness of current template offerings, I'm getting a little pessimistic.
Quote
 
 
#3 Jo snow 2010-02-07 00:09
Interesting and highly motivating Perspective.. I still feel though that this is a critical juncture for Joomla as a framework. The last year has been less than stellar and even though this has been more widely recognized over the past 90 days or so thanks to commentators like yourself - It still remains to be seen whether 1.6 is the leap, if it isn't or if its too late then entrepreneurs will make the leap to another ecosystem followed shortly thereafter by the users.

Such is life
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh